In any organization, members may face a challenging situation when leadership prioritizes self-preservation over organizational integrity and fails to address violations of policies, regulations, and rules. This article explores what members can do, why taking action matters, and examines real-world examples that provide valuable lessons.
Special Considerations for Member-Based Organizations
This guide is particularly relevant for members of:
Fraternities and Sororities
Student Organizations
Nonprofit Organizations
Religious Organizations
Social Clubs
Professional Associations
Volunteer Groups
Alumni Organizations
Academic Honor Societies
Service Organizations
These member-based organizations present unique challenges when leadership fails to address misconduct, as they often involve:
Complex power dynamics between members and leadership
Strong social and emotional ties between members
Pressure to maintain tradition and reputation
Limited oversight from external authorities
Volunteer leadership with varying levels of experience
Generational leadership transitions
Strong emphasis on loyalty and brotherhood/sisterhood
Risk of social ostracism for speaking up
Informal communication channels
Limited formal HR structures
Understanding the Stakes in Member Organizations
When leadership in member-based organizations fails to address serious violations like harassment, threats of violence, hazing, or retaliatory behavior, the consequences can be particularly severe due to:
Close-knit nature of these communities
Ongoing social and professional relationships
Impact on academic or career opportunities
Potential loss of membership benefits
Risk to organizational charter or recognition
Personal safety in shared living spaces
Mental health impact from betrayal of trust
Family and legacy relationships
Damage to lifelong affiliations
Risk to educational opportunities
Immediate physical and psychological harm to victims
Severe trauma and mental health impacts on affected individuals
Creation of a culture of fear and silence
Legal liability for both the organization and individual leaders
Violations of civil rights and human dignity
Erosion of organizational safety and security
Increased turnover and difficulty retaining talented staff
Long-term damage to organizational reputation
Potential criminal liability for failure to act
Systemic discrimination and hostile work environment claims
Steps Members Can Take
1. Document Everything
When facing serious violations like harassment or threats, thorough documentation becomes crucial:
Record specific incidents with exact dates, times, and locations
Note all witnesses present during incidents
Save all communications including emails, texts, voicemails, and messages
Document physical evidence like security camera footage before it's deleted
Keep copies of all formal complaints and responses
Record any retaliatory actions or threats
Maintain a detailed timeline of events and reporting attempts
Save screenshots or photographs of relevant evidence
Keep records in a secure location outside of work
Make backup copies of all documentation
Documentation protects you and creates a clear timeline of events that may prove crucial later.
2. Know Your Rights and Resources
For member-based organizations, understand:
Institutional Policies:
University/College conduct codes (for student organizations)
National organization bylaws and standards
Local chapter regulations
Host institution policies
Title IX protections (if applicable)
Anti-hazing laws
Membership rights and responsibilities
Available Resources:
University/College administration
National organization headquarters
Campus safety/security
Student affairs offices
Greek life offices
Faculty advisors
Alumni, Regional, Province, District or National boards
State nonprofit regulators
Accrediting bodies
National watchdog organizations
3. Build Support Networks
In member organizations, identify and connect with:
Trusted alumni members
Faculty/Staff advisors
National organization representatives
Other chapter presidents or leaders
Campus resource centers
Student government representatives
Inter-fraternal or pan-hellenic councils
Professional staff at headquarters
Engaged board members
Other organization chapters
Mental health resources
Legal aid organizations
Anti-hazing advocates
Cultural/Identity-based support groups
4. Escalate Appropriately
In cases involving harassment, threats, or retaliation, proper escalation is critical:
1. Ensure Immediate Safety
Contact law enforcement if there are immediate threats
Seek medical attention if needed and document any injuries
Consider obtaining protective orders if necessary
2. Internal Reporting
File formal complaints with HR or designated officers
Report to immediate supervisor (unless they're the perpetrator)
Escalate to higher management if lower levels are unresponsive
Contact board members or trustees about serious violations
Document each reporting attempt and response
3. External Reporting
File complaints with appropriate government agencies (EEOC, OSHA, etc.)
Contact industry regulatory bodies
Report criminal behavior to law enforcement
Engage with professional licensing boards if applicable
4. Legal Protection
Consult with employment law attorneys
File formal discrimination/harassment charges
Consider restraining orders for threats
Protect your legal rights and timeline requirements
5. Seek External Support
Consider reaching out to:
Professional associations in your field
Legal counsel specializing in employment law
Industry regulators or oversight bodies
Trusted mentors outside the organization
Why Taking Action Matters
Ethical Imperatives
Members have both professional and moral obligations to address serious violations. Inaction can make you complicit and contribute to:
Continued misconduct
Erosion of professional standards
Potential harm to stakeholders
Degradation of organizational culture
Professional Growth
Taking principled action develops:
Leadership skills
Ethical decision-making abilities
Professional courage
Change management experience
Organizational Health
Member action can lead to:
Improved governance
Stronger accountability systems
Better risk management
Enhanced organizational resilience
Case Studies of Harassment and Retaliation
Penn State Fraternity Hazing Case (2017)
The death of pledge Timothy Piazza led to criminal charges and systemic changes in Greek life policies. Members who spoke up demonstrated:
Importance of immediate reporting of dangerous situations
Role of video evidence in accountability
Impact of member testimony
Need for cultural change
Value of working with law enforcement
Nonprofit Leadership Misconduct (2019)
Southern Poverty Law Center employees exposed discrimination and harassment, leading to leadership resignation and reform:
Power of collective action
Role of board engagement
Impact on donor confidence
Importance of mission alignment
Value of public accountability
National Sorority Discrimination Case (2020)
Members challenged discriminatory membership practices, resulting in policy changes:
Strength of social media advocacy
Role of alumni networks
Impact of media attention
Value of documented patterns
Importance of inclusive policies
Special Challenges in Member Organizations
1. Handling Legacy Relationships
Navigate family connections
Address generational pressure
Manage alumni relationships
Balance tradition with change
Consider long-term impact
2. Managing Social Consequences
Prepare for social isolation
Handle peer pressure
Maintain academic/professional relationships
Protect personal reputation
Support affected members
3. Protecting Organizational Stability
Consider chapter survival
Maintain organizational recognition
Preserve positive traditions
Protect organizational assets
Manage membership retention
4. Addressing Systemic Issues
Challenge toxic culture
Reform outdated practices
Update governance structures
Implement accountability measures
Develop sustainable solutions
Member Organization Action Framework
1. Immediate Response
- Assess immediate safety concerns
- Document incidents thoroughly
- Report to appropriate authorities
- Secure evidence and communications
- Protect vulnerable members
2. Internal Channels
Contact chapter advisors
Report to national headquarters
Engage alumni board
Notify faculty supervisors
Submit formal complaints
3. Institution-Level Action
File university/college reports
Contact student affairs
Engage Greek life office
Submit Title IX complaints
Request administrative review
4. External Support
Contact advocacy organizations
Seek legal assistance
Engage oversight bodies
Connect with support services
Build media relationships
5. Long-Term Reform
Propose policy changes
Develop safety protocols
Create accountability systems
Establish reporting mechanisms
Build sustainable leadership
Practical Tips for Handling Serious Violations
1. Prioritize Personal Safety
Remove yourself from dangerous situations
Create a personal safety plan
Consider working remotely if possible
Install security systems if needed
Keep emergency contacts readily available
2. Protect Your Mental Health
Seek counseling or therapy
Join support groups
Maintain work-life boundaries
Practice self-care
Build a support network
3. Secure Your Professional Standing
Document performance reviews
Save positive feedback
Track accomplishments
Maintain professional relationships
Prepare for possible career transitions
4. Build Strong Support Systems
Connect with advocacy organizations
Join professional associations
Engage with employee resource groups
Find mentors outside the organization
Network with industry colleagues
5. Navigate Legal Channels
Understand reporting deadlines
Know your rights and protections
Maintain attorney-client privilege
Follow proper reporting procedures
Preserve evidence properly
Conclusion
When organizational leadership fails to uphold standards and protect the institution's integrity, members have both the right and responsibility to take action. Success requires careful planning, documentation, and strategic thinking. While taking action carries risks, the alternatives – allowing violations to continue unchecked or becoming complicit through silence – often carry greater long-term costs, both personally and professionally.
Remember that you're not alone in facing these challenges. Many successful reforms and positive changes have started with individual members who had the courage to speak up and take appropriate action.
Disclaimer: This article provides general guidance and should not be considered legal advice. Consult with appropriate legal counsel and professional advisors for specific situations.*
Comments